Admitting Testimony Regarding Business Records

Proving the Existence of a Contract

If the parties dispute whether a contract was formed, ordinarily testimony about the parties’ oral and written communications, and actions consistent or inconsistent with contract formation, would come into evidence.  “Whether parties have reached a contractual agreement and on what terms are questions for the fact finder when conflicting versions of the parties’ negotiations require a determination of credibility.”  Hebberd-Kulow Enterprises, Inc. v. Kelomar, Inc., 218 Cal.App.4th 272, 283 (2013).  I represented a plaintiff which proved formation of an oral joint venture through oral testimony, follow up emails and a pre-dispute pattern of profit splitting. read more

Trimming Pretrial Depositions

In civil business trials, the parties, and witnesses with information within the broad scope of discovery, may be subjected to pretrial “depositions” – oral examinations under oath taken prior to trial.  The “person” deposed may be a natural person or an organization.  Cal. Civ. Proc. Code § 2025.010; FRCP R.30.  While courts impose a presumptive time limitation on depositions, often seven hours – FRCP R.30(d)(1), Cal. Civ. Proc. Code § 2025.290(a) – those limits have exceptions, the parties may be reluctant to go to court to enforce the limitations, and the judge can grant relief under the circumstances.

Where a witness’s testimony is needed and they cannot be compelled to attend the trial, it will be necessary to conduct a full direct and cross-examination, as the deposition testimony is the only means by which that witness’s testimony will be received at trial.  read more

Admitting Records in Business Trials

A business trial lawyer’s case lives and dies on getting communications and records into evidence. While injury cases may focus on accident or surgical reconstruction, photos and videos, medical records and lost wages, business evidence weighs toward communications, contracts, financial statements and expert damage calculations. The challenge is getting those records into evidence over objections that they constitute inadmissible hearsay.

Let’s start with hearsay basics: Hearsay evidence is a statement made other than by a witness testifying at the trial offered to prove the truth of the matter stated. Cal. Ev. Code § 1200(a).

Statement of independent or operative significance

Certain statements may have independent legal significance and are therefore not offered for the truth of the matter stated. read more

Making Business Cases Relatable: Lessons from High School

“Consumer” trial lawyers handle situations that an average juror may have personally experienced or at least can relate to – for example accidents resulting in injuries, negligent medical treatment, sexual assault or harassment or employment discrimination. The human element is immediately apparent, and the stakes feel personal.
“Business” trial lawyers, by contrast, often handle situations that a judge or average juror may never have personally experienced and could have trouble understanding – investment fraud, director or officer liability, breach of fiduciary duties, contract or licensing, infringement of intellectual property or non-medical professional negligence. These cases can feel abstract, removed from everyday experience, and frankly, less sympathetic. read more

High Stakes Entertainment Litigation – Lessons Learned

Spillane Trial Group was delighted to be selected to defend Cross Creek, a top independent film producer whose first effort was Academy Award winner “Black Swan,” in a case eminently heading toward trial filed by French entertainment giant Studiocanal.   A Cross Creek entity had contracted with Studiocanal to pay $5 million for rights to distribute “Legend,” a British Tom Hardy gangster film, in the U.S. and Canada.  Concerned that Universal’s limited release plans for “Legend” frustrated the expectations of the film’s U.S. investors, Cross Creek returned the investment funds rather than pay Studiocanal.  Studiocanal obtained a judgment for breach of contract, then initiated action against numerous Cross Creek entities and insiders with omnibus theories including fraud, successor liability and intentional interference with contract.  read more